David Emery OnlineTools of a different trade
4 June 2010
Photoshop and Fireworks are great tools …for tweaking photos and creating icons, gradients and textures. When it comes to laying out web pages however, they are worse than substandard. They are actively harmful. They reinforce the incorrect idea that there is a way of representing the browsing experience in anything other than a browser.
It’s always nice to see yourself quoted somewhere, and it’s also nice to see this issue gain a bit more relevance now we have devices like the iPad.
However, I do disagree with the idea that you should forego Photoshop and other such tools for the most part and design in the browser. Yes in the browser it’s much easier to see how a design will react to different window sizes and the like, but – certainly for me, at least – I think it can lead to unimaginative design.
It’s just too easy to make things simple when designing in a browser, and be lead by the code as opposed to being lead by the design. It is hard to visualise how a page will behave when designing it in Photoshop, but I find that’s better then trying to visualise design from within a text editor.
Visit ➔